Insights

2024 Mid-Year Commentary Outlook

First Half 2024 Grander Update:

The first half of 2024 has been dominated by Fed speculation – when will they drop rates? How quickly will they do so? – but the real story in mortgage markets was the ongoing lack of supply and continued resilience of mortgage rates. For MSR investors, the news has been terrific – unless you’re trying to source more product at cheap valuations. For fixed income markets as a whole, however, this steady picture and the range-bound market associated with it is starting to show signs of change.

Fixed Income Markets
Long term rates have traded in a 75-bps range since the beginning of the year, after starting the year just south of 4%, rates peaked in late April around 4.60% and have traded down to the current 4.25% range. The trading range has been unconvincing; small perceptions of future risks (the potential for a Republican sweep of the White House, Senate and House, for example) has been enough to create outsized moves. Supply – demonstrated by repeat “biggest ever” note and bond auctions by Treasury – remains robust, with rate pressure further strengthened by Fed portfolio shrinkage and the beginning of the baby boomer retirement drawdown trade. The bias remains towards higher long-term rates, in other words, although it will likely require more news to convincingly break out one way or another.
At the shorter end of the curve, two-year rates remain locked in a 4.25-4.50% range, as Fed speak almost immediately counteracts any suggestion of sooner or faster rate reduction. Chair Powell and the other governors have been remarkably consistent in their verbiage, and similarly all on message that rates will only be lowered with clear evidence of reduced inflation within their range – and as long as headline CPI and core have a 3% handle, that evidence is lacking. Moreover, until consumer confidence worsens, or unemployment rears its head, the Fed has no real push to drop rates.
Spread product has been largely range-bound, although markets are starting to differentiate between what are seen as “low risk” spread product – investment grade credit, conforming and guaranteed mortgage paper – and “higher risk” product such as CMBS and non-dollar bonds. Supply is modest YTD, but large corporate issuance in 2019-2021, driven by low rates and cash hoarding in the pandemic, should result in significant rollover activity and pre-positioning in the second half of the year.
Mortgage and MSR Environment
For mortgages, that picture – a locked front end, effectively no steepness to the curve, and a trend towards overall selling in the market – has kept new issuance coupons locked at 6.0%, off of new origination pools – small as they are – in the low 7% range. That has kept effectively all refinance incentive out of the market, and numbers suggest it’s also limited new purchase volumes effectively to first-time home buyers and “forced” sellers (due to moves, family events, etc.). New home construction remains at sectoral lows, and existing home sales fully describe the low single digit voluntary CPRs seen in vintage pools.
What does this mean? For existing MSR owners of vintage pools, the result has been slower prepayments, higher valuations, and lower than expected involuntary prepayments. For originators, it means a low amount of activity – with companies chasing any MSR paper which may offer an opportunity to refinance or market second liens to borrowers, but a gradual slowing of activity in very deep in-the-money MSR pool trading. That need for originator activity, though, has resulted in tighter spreads, helpful to investor valuations even though supply constraints are making it challenging to find product.
Importantly for modelling, we’re now entering the third full year of mortgage origination rates being 3% or more higher than the bulk of outstanding conforming mortgage paper, allowing us to gain more and more confidence in our prepayment behavior model and how deep in-the-money borrowers behave “in real life”. With most homes in the money from an HPI perspective, there is little incentive to move except when absolutely necessary, and yet we have not seen the uptick in second lien volumes which might reflect an exhaustion process with homeowners in an existing, aging home. While we will look with concern to any erosion in the broad economy, with unemployment at lows normally associated with higher inflation, we do not see significant weakening in borrower strength in the near future – which should continue to lock in low CPRs for yet another annual cycle.
Performance for Grander’s pools continues to beat the expectations made at time of purchase for prepayments – both voluntary and involuntary – and our predictive model for geographic relative performance is also doing well. GMOF 1 lifetime performance continues to play out in a range that will lead to life-of-fund returns in the low 20% range, while more recent pools indicate expected lifetime performance in the high teens.
Outlook
With July 4th behind us in a presidential election year, all focus will now be on November and the election. We aren’t political prognosticators here at Grander, but the markets are viewing signs of a Republican sweep with some worry: one political party holding the House, the Senate, and the Oval Office tends to lead towards higher deficits and more extreme macroeconomic policies. In an environment where the Fed is still worried about overheating in the economy, that would tend to suggest higher rates on the long end, wider spreads, and more volatility. For MSR holders, that should be to the good – cash flows should remain robust, and both voluntary and involuntary prepayments should remain muted – but the uncertainty can affect trading and valuation spreads. We’ll have more to say once we get past Election Day.
About Grander
Grander was formed in 2017 as Grander Investment Management LLC and Grander Mortgage Capital LLC. Robert Williams, and Curtis Whitaker are named as co-founders. Combined they bring 60+ years of Banking and Capital Markets relationships forged over multiple economic and market cycles. Established as a Master Servicer in all but four states, Grander has secured State and Federal license approval as an “approved” seller servicer for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans. Consideration to obtain GNMA approval in the future. Grander has partnered with strategic organizations on Subservicing and Recapture programs seeking to build long-term relationships and ensuring that recapture economics and incentives align across all parties.
Our “Value Proposition”
Grander’s mission is to foster life-long client relationships based on a foundation of trust and client satisfaction. Our value is supported by our seasoned investment professionals who have successfully managed investment portfolios throughout their career, bringing a unique perspective with diverse backgrounds, experience, and knowledge of financial markets. We strive for opportunity to access value creation outside the public markets within the Mortgage Service Rights space. Grander continues to develop future-oriented investment solutions to invest the assets of our clients in a risk-controlled and performance focused manner.

Please contact your Grander representative should you have questions or if you would like any additional information. Our investor relations Team can be reached at (424)-278-9060.

⦁ Confidentiality – Information presented within this document is confidential and proprietary to Grander Mortgage Holdings LLC, Grander Investment Management LLC (“GIM”), the Grander Mortgage Funds and respective affiliates (collectively, “Grander”) and may not be reproduced in whole or in part or used for any purpose except as authorized by GIM. This document is strictly confidential and is for the recipient’s use only. Recipient acknowledges and agrees that this document and any confidential information contained herein shall not to be disclosed directly or indirectly to any other party by the recipient and, by accepting receipt of this document, the recipient agrees to comply with this restriction and confirms its understanding of the limitations set forth in this disclaimer.
⦁ Nature of Information Provided – These materials have been prepared by GIM as a summary solely for informational purposes. These materials are not, and should not be assumed to be, complete. Nothing within this document shall constitute an offer to sell any securities or constitute solicitation of an offer to purchase securities. Any such offer to sell, or solicitation of an offer to purchase, shall be made only by the offering documents (if any) and the subscription documents (together with the offering documents (if any), the “Offering Materials”) of Grander. These materials are qualified entirely by such Offering Materials, which should be read carefully prior to any investment. Any investment decision should be based only on the information in such offering documents. Interests or MetLife in Grander have not been registered under the Securities Act of 1933 (the “Securities Act”). GIM is relying on one or more exceptions from registration under the Securities Act. GIM has not been registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940 and is relying on one or more exemptions therefrom.
⦁
⦁ Past Performance – In considering any performance information contained within these documents, you should bear in mind that past or projected performance is not necessarily indicative of future results, and there can be no assurance that any entity referenced within these documents will achieve comparable results or that target returns, if any, will be met.
⦁
⦁ Forward Looking Statements – This document contains certain forward‐looking statements or statements that may be deemed or construed to be forward‐looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 with respect to Grander’s financial condition and business. The words “may,” “will,” “should,” “could,” “anticipate,” “predict,” “potential,” “estimate,” “plan,” “intend,” “believe,” “expect,” “proposed,” and similar expressions are intended to identify forward ‐looking statements. These forward‐looking statements involve and are subject to known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that could cause Grander’s actual results, performance (financial or operating) or achievements to differ from anticipated future results. Potential investors are cautioned not to place undue reliance on these forward ‐looking statements, which speak only as of the date hereof. Forward‐looking statements are based on a number of assumptions as to future events that are inherently uncertain and subjective. No representation or warranty is made as to whether such assumptions will be proved to be correct or whether future results will occur as projected. The forward‐looking statements have been prepared solely by Grander and do not comply with any guidelines established by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants or any other similar authority. There can be no assurances that any of the expected results will be attained. Actual results could differ significantly from those currently anticipated due to a number of factors.